Mastering the Ninja Warrior's Kamae - The Difference Between "Doing" & "Becoming"

One of the first lessons that a new student tobeing a rigid, mechanical form, any given kamae
the art of Ninjutsu must learn involves learning thebegins in the Ninja's heart - his feelings and
positions of safety, known as kamaeemotional state created by his relationship to the
(kah-mah-eh). These "postures," while they appearsituation he's in - which, in-turn, causes the body
to be identical to the stances used by many ofto shift and move into a physical position that
the more conventional martial arts, are actuallyreflects this internal, emotional state.
quite different - both in function and in the way 
they are created.As an example of this principle in action, when the
 ninja is being overwhelmed by a bigger, stronger
In the conventional martial art that I practicedadversary, he allows his feelings of overwhelm to
before discovering ninjutsu, stances weremove his body back and away from the assailant
approached from the perspective of being- while blading the body to the attacker and
something you had to learn to move on to thebringing the arms up to naturally cover his targets.
really cool stuff. They were set, unchangingAgain, rather than take up a preset, "official" form
"forms" that were taken up with the body anddictated by the chosen "style," the Ninja warrior
from which the punches, kicks, and othergoes with his internal feelings that come up and
techniques originated.then applies effective principles of effective
 movement and defense to create his kamae.
Even in modern ninjutsu practice, the majority of 
students fall into one of two categories:Another example of this principle is the Ninja who
 is being threatened by the attacker who uses a
 wind up, or hauling-off type of attack. In this
 case, the Ninja might not be able to back up, so
My focus in this article is to discuss the differencegoing with his intense drive to "go-for-it," he
in how kamae are usually taken up by studentsmoves into the jumonji no kamae or kosei no
and teachers alike, and how they are supposed tokamae ("attacking tiger posture") as he takes the
be used. The difference is outside of the wayfight to his aggressor.
that most martial artists think. That's because... 
 The art of the Ninja often runs contrary to the
...the difference is between "doing" the kamae, andconventional logic used to guide many of the
"BECOMING" the kamae!more popular martial arts of our time. It's this
 "natural" approach and holistic perspective that
Contrary to the mechanical method that mostuses the mind, body, and spirit - not just for
people use to take up a defensive stance, themeditation and philosophical training - that allows
Ninja's defensive postures are actually holisticthe shadow warrior to be exactly where he or
expressions of the Ninja's heart reflected throughshe needs to be to defeat the assailant's attack
his body. What that means is that, rather thanwith the exact technique needed to win.